# Comparison of coral calcification response in Palau Porites coral to reponses observed in other studies # PI: Anne Cohen (WHOI) # Contact: Hannah Barkley (WHOI) # Version: 30 June 2017 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Albright_et_al._2008 Florida Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 2.2 -0.88 2.23 -1.01 2.61 -0.53 2.62 0.16 3.1 0.71 3.2 1.54 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Anthony_et_al._2008 Australia Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.72 -1.37 1.92 -0.88 2.82 0.42 3.13 0.79 4.77 1.23 5.22 -0.2 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Barkley_et_al._2015 Palau Field ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 2.3 -2.07 2.3 -1.21 2.3 -0.77 2.3 -0.74 2.3 -0.32 2.3 -0.21 2.3 -0.17 2.3 -0.07 2.3 -0.06 2.3 0.08 2.3 0.41 2.3 1.38 3.7 -1.68 3.7 -1.43 3.7 -0.83 3.7 -0.47 3.7 -0.31 3.7 0.29 3.7 0.53 3.7 0.74 3.7 1.43 3.7 1.56 3.7 1.75 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Barkley_et_al._2017 Palau Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.36 0.45 1.37 0.06 1.38 -0.24 1.4 0.24 1.41 1.17 1.43 -1.11 1.43 0.24 1.45 0.17 1.46 -0.34 1.46 0.64 1.46 0.86 1.5 -0.48 1.5 -0.3 1.54 1.08 1.55 -0.51 1.57 -1.22 1.58 -2.11 1.58 0.69 1.59 0.21 2.18 0.16 2.22 -1.34 2.22 -0.75 2.22 0.86 2.22 1.06 2.24 0.27 2.25 1.06 2.26 0.18 2.28 -0.5 2.29 -0.07 2.32 -1.67 2.32 0.9 2.33 -0.23 2.36 -2.45 2.37 -0.56 2.39 0.39 2.4 -1.11 2.42 -0.38 2.49 -1.57 2.53 -0.59 2.79 1.23 2.91 1.41 2.91 1.42 2.94 1 2.96 -1.35 2.98 -0.85 2.98 -0.57 2.98 1.11 2.99 -0.45 3 0.96 3.01 -0.07 3.02 -0.6 3.03 0.5 3.04 -1.39 3.04 0.76 3.12 -0.8 3.12 0.82 3.12 1 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Barkley_et_al._2017 Palau Transplant ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 2.3 -1.82 2.3 -1.48 2.3 -1.42 2.3 -1.39 2.3 -0.94 2.3 -0.76 2.3 -0.72 2.3 -0.29 2.3 -0.26 2.3 -0.24 2.3 -0.2 2.3 0.05 2.3 0.21 2.3 0.45 2.3 0.49 2.3 0.55 2.3 0.63 2.3 0.74 2.3 0.81 2.3 1.24 2.3 1.31 2.3 1.4 2.3 1.66 3.7 -1.74 3.7 -1.6 3.7 -1.52 3.7 -0.95 3.7 -0.74 3.7 -0.69 3.7 -0.42 3.7 -0.27 3.7 0.05 3.7 0.16 3.7 0.17 3.7 0.17 3.7 0.24 3.7 0.31 3.7 0.38 3.7 1.08 3.7 1.14 3.7 1.23 3.7 1.39 3.7 1.62 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Comeau_et_al._2014 Hawaii Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.83 -1.49 1.83 -1.47 1.83 -1.17 1.83 -1.12 1.83 -0.87 1.83 -0.74 1.83 -0.69 1.83 -0.19 1.83 0.04 1.83 0.46 1.83 0.98 1.83 1.52 2.36 -1.2 2.36 -0.97 2.36 -0.96 2.36 -0.53 2.36 -0.37 2.36 -0.13 2.36 -0.06 2.36 -0.02 2.36 0 2.36 0.06 2.36 0.47 2.36 1.13 3.31 -0.97 3.31 -0.71 3.31 -0.48 3.31 -0.26 3.31 -0.15 3.31 -0.12 3.31 -0.06 3.31 -0.06 3.31 0.12 3.31 0.28 3.31 0.43 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Comeau_et_al._2014 Japan Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.91 -0.55 1.91 -0.14 1.91 -0.14 1.91 0 1.91 0.23 1.91 0.47 1.91 0.5 1.91 1.04 1.91 1.06 1.91 1.07 1.91 1.4 1.91 1.87 2.36 -0.95 2.36 -0.31 2.36 -0.26 2.36 0.34 2.36 0.48 2.36 0.61 2.36 0.86 2.36 1.18 2.36 1.45 2.36 1.69 2.36 2.04 2.36 2.06 3.24 -0.28 3.24 0.31 3.24 0.65 3.24 0.73 3.24 0.89 3.24 1 3.24 1.04 3.24 1.08 3.24 1.32 3.24 1.81 3.24 1.84 3.24 1.97 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Comeau_et_al._2014 Moorea Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.99 -2.05 1.99 -1.45 1.99 -1.2 1.99 -0.98 1.99 -0.63 1.99 -0.36 2 -0.69 2 0.07 2 0.13 2 0.17 2 0.2 2 0.22 2.68 -0.71 2.68 -0.48 2.68 -0.3 2.68 0.14 2.68 0.17 2.69 -1.68 2.69 -1.64 2.69 -1.17 2.69 -0.1 2.69 0.1 2.69 0.79 3.83 -0.93 3.83 -0.41 3.83 -0.35 3.83 -0.29 3.83 0.17 3.83 0.26 3.85 -1.79 3.85 -1.03 3.85 0.6 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Crook_et_al_2013 Yucatan Field ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 0.77 -1.19 0.81 -1.7 1.22 -0.34 1.82 -0.68 1.82 -0.46 1.85 -0.32 1.9 0.2 3.6 0.69 3.6 1.46 3.83 -0.51 4.03 -0.13 4.03 0.36 4.12 2.11 4.24 0.52 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- dePutron_et_al._2011 Bermuda Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.41 -2 1.41 -1.74 1.41 -1.68 1.41 -1.58 1.41 -1.54 1.41 -1.29 1.41 -1.29 1.41 -1.29 1.41 -1.28 1.41 -1.18 1.41 -1.13 1.41 -1.13 1.41 -1.11 1.41 -0.9 1.41 -0.77 1.41 -0.77 1.41 -0.77 1.41 -0.64 1.41 -0.63 1.41 -0.63 1.41 -0.6 1.41 -0.54 1.41 -0.53 1.41 -0.48 1.41 -0.44 1.41 -0.38 1.41 -0.26 1.41 -0.21 1.41 -0.13 1.41 -0.12 1.41 0.39 1.41 0.53 1.41 0.54 1.41 0.82 2.84 -1.55 2.84 -1.43 2.84 -1.35 2.84 -1.23 2.84 -1.21 2.84 -1.17 2.84 -1 2.84 -0.9 2.84 -0.9 2.84 -0.76 2.84 -0.76 2.84 -0.67 2.84 -0.63 2.84 -0.57 2.84 -0.56 2.84 -0.56 2.84 -0.48 2.84 -0.47 2.84 -0.44 2.84 -0.37 2.84 -0.36 2.84 -0.09 2.84 -0.06 2.84 0.02 2.84 0.08 2.84 0.11 2.84 0.16 2.84 0.2 2.84 0.22 2.84 0.26 2.84 0.3 2.84 0.34 2.84 0.49 2.84 0.57 2.84 0.59 2.84 0.6 2.84 0.62 2.84 0.63 2.84 0.74 2.84 0.74 2.84 0.77 2.84 0.86 2.84 0.97 2.84 1.29 2.84 1.29 2.84 1.37 2.84 1.38 2.84 2.27 2.84 2.41 2.84 2.56 4 -1.45 4 -1.38 4 -1.38 4 -1.35 4 -1.34 4 -1.28 4 -1.16 4 -1.15 4 -1.1 4 -1 4 -0.95 4 -0.92 4 -0.9 4 -0.9 4 -0.87 4 -0.87 4 -0.86 4 -0.84 4 -0.84 4 -0.83 4 -0.8 4 -0.71 4 -0.7 4 -0.7 4 -0.67 4 -0.46 4 -0.41 4 -0.41 4 -0.4 4 -0.36 4 -0.34 4 -0.32 4 -0.28 4 -0.23 4 -0.23 4 -0.16 4 -0.11 4 -0.08 4 -0.07 4 -0.07 4 -0.07 4 -0.04 4 -0.01 4 0.01 4 0.03 4 0.04 4 0.06 4 0.14 4 0.17 4 0.18 4 0.18 4 0.19 4 0.2 4 0.24 4 0.24 4 0.3 4 0.3 4 0.3 4 0.3 4 0.3 4 0.3 4 0.34 4 0.37 4 0.38 4 0.38 4 0.38 4 0.42 4 0.42 4 0.47 4 0.49 4 0.53 4 0.58 4 0.69 4 0.69 4 0.7 4 0.82 4 0.87 4 0.89 4 0.9 4 0.96 4 1.03 4 1.07 4 1.24 4 1.25 4 1.27 4 1.29 4 1.37 4 1.42 4 1.5 4 1.54 4 1.63 4 1.68 4 1.74 4 1.96 4 2.17 4 2.24 4 2.34 4 2.59 4 2.6 4 2.64 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Edmunds_2012 Moorea Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.7 -0.12 1.7 -0.04 1.7 0.08 1.7 1.08 1.7 1.6 1.78 -0.92 1.78 -0.8 1.78 -0.48 1.78 0.12 1.78 1.52 1.93 -2.72 1.93 -0.44 1.93 0.24 1.93 0.92 1.93 1.24 2.02 -2.19 2.02 -1.51 2.02 -1.28 2.02 -0.95 2.02 0.39 2.08 -1.1 2.08 -0.33 2.08 -0.09 2.08 1.29 2.08 1.84 2.11 -1.68 2.11 -1.6 2.11 -0.68 2.11 -0.6 2.11 0.2 2.22 -1.05 2.22 0.34 2.22 0.77 2.22 0.89 2.22 1.34 2.26 -0.75 2.26 -0.71 2.26 -0.69 2.26 1.31 2.68 -0.4 2.68 -0.24 2.68 -0.12 2.68 0.04 2.68 0.6 2.69 -0.56 2.69 0.04 2.69 0.12 2.69 0.44 2.69 0.8 2.92 -1.16 2.92 0.28 2.92 0.36 2.92 0.36 2.92 0.96 2.96 -1.64 2.96 -0.84 2.96 0.2 2.96 1.4 2.96 2.28 3.29 -0.7 3.29 -0.2 3.29 -0.18 3.29 0.78 3.29 1.19 3.37 -0.2 3.37 -0.02 3.37 0.07 3.37 0.75 3.37 0.99 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Enochs_et_al._2015 Maug Field ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 3.39 -0.58 3.66 -0.58 3.84 1.16 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Iguchi_et_al._2012 Japan Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1 -1.25 1 -1.12 1 -0.41 1.5 -0.51 1.5 -0.44 1.5 0.87 3.5 0.46 3.5 0.62 3.5 1.79 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Manzello_et_al._2014 Galapagos Field ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 2.42 -1.23 2.83 -0.25 3.02 0.32 3.28 1.15 ========================= reference site study_type ------------------------- Ohde_and_Hossain_2004 Japan Laboratory ========================= omega_AR standardized_calcification_anom ------------------------- 1.08 -1.62 1.16 -1.58 1.37 -0.36 1.61 0.44 1.68 -1.28 1.8 -1.43 1.81 -1.43 1.82 -1.24 1.82 -1.03 1.9 -0.46 1.95 -0.51 2.1 0.02 2.33 -1.07 2.6 -1.72 2.86 -0.3 3.15 0.78 3.53 -0.67 3.65 -0.59 3.69 -0.74 3.74 -0.48 3.75 0.25 3.83 0.15 4.01 0.59 4.07 1.18 4.24 -0.11 4.61 -0.59 4.98 -0.32 5 0.29 5.02 1.6 5.13 -0.38 5.25 0.44 5.27 1.09 5.3 -0.36 5.31 1.51 5.52 1.13 5.58 0.92 5.78 0.17 6.17 -0.21 6.34 2.75 6.4 1.18 6.94 0.27 7.21 1.64 7.26 0 7.27 0.63 7.36 0.44 7.56 1.01